The Pros and Cons of Scribophile

For those of you who are serious about writing, nothing is more important than revising  your work, to make it better than how it first began. The real trick is to find readers who will offer you supportive, constructive feedback.

I recently joined Scribophile, as many of you might be aware, so for today I’d like to talk about the benefits, as well as some of the faults or downsides of the site. Scrib isn’t the only site you can use to get critiqued, but I’ve tried out a few and I think so far this one is my favorite.

The Basics

Scribophile is free for those who don’t want to spend the money, although of course there are a fair few perks for those willing to pay. Essentially, the site is broken down in a way that I find quite appealing: If you want your work critiqued, you have to earn karma points, which you earn by critiquing the works of others.

The karma system makes it easy to post things, while also ensuring that people give as much as they’re willing to take.

You can favorite writers, and follow along their writing journey by getting notifications every time they post a new chapter. You can join groups, where like-minded individuals can come together and ask questions and get the opinions of others.

The Benefits

Obviously, there’s the benefit of getting several experienced (or perhaps not so experienced, but every critique usually has something of value, even if you have to go looking for it) eyes looking over your chapters and telling what works and what doesn’t. Is there enough description? Does the dialogue feel strange? People will answer these questions, acting as your beta readers. And since they don’t know you personally, the Scribblers won’t really be worried about offending you. Most of them are really nice, from what I can tell, bu they’re there to help, not to coddle.

Scribophile’s also got a blog where its authors write out some writing and publishing tips and advice for newbies. Even better, it’s got contests that you can enter to help get your name out there.

The groups are nice too, although I haven’t yet had time to explore the forums or anything. As you can likely tell if you’ve been following my blog, things have been a bit hectic around here 🙂

The Downsides

I think perhaps the largest issue I’ve had with the site is simply finding a chapter 1 or chapter 0 (prologue) in the mess of half-finished novels. I have no problem reading Chapter 4 or 5 or even 28 without having read the preceding chapters… not really… but it’s sort of difficult to comment on a chapter and how it contributes to the plot, character arcs, etc. if you don’t know what came before.

I’ve taken to looking at the New Members Spotlight, since these people generally (for good reason) submit their first chapter as their first submission.

My other issue, and a relatively small one at that, is that a chapter only stays in the spotlight until it gets 3 critiques. It’s good for everyone else who is waiting for their turn at being critiqued, but it would be nice if an author could get four or five critiques, rather than 3, because the more eyes that have looked on it, the more opinions you have. You can use extra karma points to put it back in the spotlight, but I haven’t quite figured out how to do that yet.

Anyway, overall, it’s a nice site to use, because it’s an entire network of authors who can offer support when you need it, and can offer advice as well. If you’re thinking about joining, look me up. I’d love to see and critique stories you might be working on.


6 thoughts on “The Pros and Cons of Scribophile

  1. I’m also on Scribophile and used the site for a few years. I use to be on but the site’s been taken down. And I still have an account with You Write On and Book Country though I hardly use them. Scribophile my site of choice though I ‘ve been a ghost therre the past few months too. I love the forums where you can pose questions, meet and befriend other writers. I have the same issue with not being able to find a chapter 1 or prologue to read and critique first. Another issue I have is that they don’t have different karma system for poems or shorter works like flash fiction.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I can see why poems or really short short stories might require a different karma system, since they’d have a much lower word count, but if a flash fiction piece is 3,000 words, ehh. I doubt there’d be much of an issue in that case

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yeah, 3k words isn’t much of an issue. But when the piece is less than 1k words…There have been more and more competitions asking entrants to write a story in 100 words or 500. In order to not waste your karma points on such short pieces, you have to put multiple pieces together to critique. Personally, I feel that the poems can split the reader’s concentration and assessment in dissecting a poem as poetry is subjective. And requires multiple readings to fully contemplate it.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Top tip: join some groups and post your work under the personal spotlight, rather than the queued one. You’ll get 6 critiques in the spotlight before it reduces instead of just 3. Anyone in the same group as you will be able to critique it. You just need to let them know it’s there… make friends, do a critique exchange, whatever.

    Hope you get into it. I love the site.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I like the idea of the personal spotlight, although I haven’t used it yet. (I will note, for readers, that personal spotlight only comes with the paid version.) The problem with that particular spotlight is that I believe it is most effective if you’ve made a group of friends on Scribophile, and you do that by doing lots of critiques. With how busy I am, it’s difficult for me to find time to spend critiquing a piece, especially when it means sacrificing my own precious writing time to do so. As I said, though, I think Scribophile is one of the best ones out there. It’s just… you know… time consuming.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Ah, yes, you’re quite right. Forgot that was a paid-for feature. That, the 2-works-at-a-time maximum and the 10-message limit in your Scribophile Inbox were the reasons I upgraded. And that’s quite the tactic on their part – you can live without those features, but you’ll soon get frustrated enough to shell out.

        If you’re in two minds, though, I will say this: I’m conscious of how much I’ve improved as a writer in the mere 4 months I’ve been on Scrib. That, to me, is worth a lot.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s